Florida Muslims forced to hide slaughter of lambs and goats

Commissioner Sheila Alu halts Muslim animal-sacrifice ceremony

Saying she is an animal-lover and acting as a private citizen, she persuaded the owners of the land where the event was to take place to withdraw their permission for it.

By Susannah Bryan
Sun Sentinel

Disturbed by the prospect of lambs and goats being slaughtered in Sunrise, City Commissioner Sheila Alu single-handedly blocked a Muslim religious ceremony scheduled to take place on Sunday.

“Yes, I was trying to stop it,” Alu said Wednesday. “It’s shut down. I’m trying to protect innocent animals. This is not an appropriate setting for the slaughtering of animals in an open field in a city that’s as populated as Sunrise. Usually these religious ceremonies take place in a rural area.”

The news did not sit well with Nezar Hamze, executive director of the South Florida Council on American-Islamic Relations, based in Pembroke Pines.

“Wow,” Hamze said. “That is very upsetting. We’ll find another venue. But that’s very disturbing. I’m very disappointed in that. We asked for permission and went through the proper channels, and now it’s off because a commissioner has a problem with it.”

Muslims from local mosques had planned to gather at a 45-acre farm off Hiatus Road in Sunrise to celebrate the Eid ul-Adha, the Festival of Sacrifice, Hamze said. The holiday honors Abraham’s willingness to sacrifice his son before God provided a sacrificial lamb instead.

The day also marks the end of the pilgrimage to Mecca that all Muslims are urged to make at least once in their lifetimes.

“The meat is sacrificed according to state and Islamic law,” Hamze said. “There is no bloodbath. It’s very humane. It’s a slit on the throat real quick. And they bleed out in a couple seconds. The animals do not suffer.”

The Florida Humane Slaughter Act governs the handling and killing of livestock, and a 1993 U.S. Supreme Court decision stemming from a case in Miami-Dade County upheld the right to perform animal sacrifices for religious purposes. That decision grew out of a lawsuit filed by the Lukumi Babalu Aye church charging the city of Hialeah with illegally enacting ordinances designed to persecute Santeria practitioners.

That means animal sacrifices for religious purposes enjoy protection from government interference, said Derek Newton, spokesman for the American Civil Liberties Union of Florida.

“If [Alu] was acting on her own, it becomes a question of politics rather than a legal argument,” Newton said. “If she called from her office and said she was commissioner so and so, that might be a problem.”

Alu said she called as a resident, not as a commissioner.

“I have no ill will toward the Muslim faith,” she said. “I’m just an animal lover.”

After learning that there were no legal grounds for blocking the ceremony, Alu said she contacted a man who works for the farm’s owners to verify that they were allowing the ceremony. She said he told her they were not aware the event was taking place on their property and that the caretaker had improperly given permission for the ceremony.

“I don’t want to interfere with anyone’s religious beliefs, but if you want to slaughter animals it should be done in a slaughterhouse,” Alu said. She says she believes it is inhumane to slaughter the animals in a field. “They stab them in the throat. It’s horrible.”

“I’m not a vegetarian,” she said. “I just don’t agree with the inhumane treatment of animals. Looking at how they’re slaughtered brings tears to my eyes.”

But Hamze said the Muslim way of slaughtering animals is more humane than a slaughterhouse. He says that sometimes a slaughterhouse will use a hammer to kill the animal, and that it takes longer for the animal to die.

The property owners, Curtis and Marilyn Deem, did not answer a message left on their home telephone. Derek Matherly, the property caretaker, ridiculed Alu’s concerns.

“I find it appalling that people are so upset when they eat lambs and goats every day,” he said. “Let’s go back a couple thousand years ago. They used to slaughter animals and then burn them for sacrifice. I don’t see the big story here. It’s not like animals are being tortured.”

Hamze said the caretaker called to cancel Wednesday evening. The ceremony, however, will take place at a different, undisclosed location.

“We found another venue,” Hamze said, “but it will be kept private.”

He also said he had spoken with Alu.

“I truly believe she’s just a big animal lover,” he said, “and I don’t believe she meant any malice toward the Muslim community.”