Friday, January 25, 2013

Punishing Innocence?

Jan. 25, 2013

It appears to me that even being proven innocent is not enough, the fact is, just being charged for a sex crime can obviously ruin your life. Unless you are a popular NBA star, what's the recourse?


Teacher removed from classroom even though charges dropped

Matthew Deppen
A Manheim Central elementary school teacher who was cleared of sex abuse charges more than a year ago was removed from Stiegel Elementary last week.

Fourth-grade teacher Matthew Deppen was placed on unpaid leave on Jan. 18 after the Pennsylvania Department of Education revoked his teaching certificate.

"At the present time, Mr. Deppen is not in the school setting, is not allowed on school property and is in an unpaid leave status," school board president Bryan Howett said in an email Thursday. "By law, at this point in time, Mr. Deppen is not permitted to teach in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania."

After 14 months of confidential hearings, the state Professional Standards and Practices Commission voted to revoke Deppen's teaching certification on Jan. 17.

According to Howett, PDE did not notify the district about the revocation until the next day.

"In less than an hour, the superintendent of schools was in contact with the district's solicitor and within a few minutes after that, Mr. Deppen was removed from the school setting," Howett said in an email.

PDE had suspended Deppen's certificate two years earlier when he was charged with sexual abuse and attempted sexual abuse of children stemming from a 2004 incident in which he videotaped children undressing in his home. Deppen also faced a second set of charges from a separate incident including endangering the welfare of children, corruption of minors, invasion of privacy and indecent assault.

During the criminal trial in October 2010, Deppen maintained that he did not intend to video record the girls changing their clothes, rather the video was supposed to record their reaction when he surprised them wearing a monkey mask.

Deppen also testified that his wife immediately took the video and, six years later, turned it in to police when the couple were going through a divorce.

Deppen was found innocent of sexual abuse and attempted sexual abuse charges. Other charges were dropped because of lack of evidence.

After Deppen's criminal charges were cleared, PDE restored his teaching credentials, and Manheim Central school board reinstated him as a teacher at Stiegel Elementary for the 2011-12 school year.

Howett said in an email that when Deppen had his credentials restored and there were no further charges against him, the district had no legal basis to prevent Deppen from returning to his teaching position.

Since then, subsequent administrative charges were filed against him to determine whether administrative action should be taken against his certification, Howett said. "PDE is entitled to conduct it's own investigation into the matter prior to filing administrative charges," Howett said. "There are different standards of proof in administrative hearings versus criminal hearings."

PDE posted a notification of its action against Deppen on its website on Jan. 17. The notification lists grounds for disciplinary action, which include "inappropriate behavior" and sexual misconduct with a minor.

Howett said Deppen has the right to appeal the decision of the Professional Standards and Practices Commission.

Lt. George Pappas of Northern Lancaster County Regional Police Department handled the case for the former Penn Township police department in 2010. He said Jan. 24 he could not comment because it was a district personnel issue.

Fred Cummins, interim district superintendent, was unavailable to comment on whether a letter was sent to notify parents of Deppen's removal.

Business Manager Nathan Wertsch said he was not involved in handling the issue, but he recalled Jan. 24 a letter being drafted.



source

No comments: